Fall
- Men's Cross Country - Brian Armijo, Southwestern University
- Women's Cross Country - Liz White, Colorado College
- Football - Weston Guzman, Texas Lutheran University
- Men's Soccer - Raghav Sharma, Southwesttern University
- Women's Soccer - Kayla Moody, Southwestern University
- Volleyball - Addyson Tiffin, McMurry University
Winter
- Men's Swimming & Diving - Wyatt Wellehan, Colorado College
- Women's Swimming & Diving - Megan Simonson, Colorado College
- Men's Basketball - Asher Nofziger, Colorado College
- Women's Basketball - Zoe Tomlinson, Colorado College
Spring
- Baseball - Dakota Palmer, Concordia University (Texas)
- Men's Golf - Bryce Stiemert, Southwestern University
- Women's Golf - Madison Meduna, University of Dallas
- Softball - Allison Hughes, University of St. Thomas
- Men's Tennis - Ashton Ellis, Southwestern University
- Women's Tennis - Daryl Locke, Southwestern University
- Men's Track & Field - Rabbit Barnes, Colorado College
- Women's Track & Field - Arden Neff, Southwestern University