Fall
- Men's Cross Country - Adam Mahler, Colorado College
- Women's Cross Country - Molly McCullough, Trinity University
- Men's Soccer - Joseph Khalaf, Austin College
- Women's Soccer - Mary Cardone, Southwestern University
- Volleyball - Brandi Campos, Southwestern University
Winter
- Men's Basketball - Danny Rivera, Trinity University
- Women's Basketball - Ann Savage, Austin College
- Men's Swimming & Diving - Jacob Hurrell-Zitelman, Trinity University
- Women's Swimming & Diving - Chaney Skilling, Colorado College
Spring
- Baseball - Cullen Motsinger, Texas Lutheran University
- Men's Golf - Devon Horne, Southwestern University
- Women's Golf - Leilani McDaniel, Southwestern University
- Men's Lacrosse - Jared Welsh, Southwestern University
- Women's Lacrosse - Cassis Schafer, Colorado College
- Softball - Hannah Ortiz, Schreiner University
- Men's Tennis - Alexis Dimanche, Southwestern University
- Women's Tennis - Mary Cardone, Southwestern University
- Men's Track & Field - Blair Walker, Trinity University
- Women's Track & Field - Allysa Warling, Colorado College